BLOG

RESOURCES

WordPress vs Website Builders: What the Format Wars Taught Us About Choosing Technology

In 1976, Sony released Betamax—a superior video format with better picture quality and more advanced technology than its competitor, VHS. By every technical measure, Betamax was the better choice. Yet by 1988, VHS had captured 95% of the market and Betamax was effectively dead. The reason? VHS offered longer recording times, more content availability, and lower costs—practical advantages that mattered more to consumers than technical superiority.

Today's website platform decision mirrors the Betamax vs VHS format war. WordPress is technically superior—more flexible, more powerful, infinitely customisable. But Wix, Squarespace, and Shopify promise simplicity, speed, and lower entry costs. For UK small businesses, the question isn't which platform is "best" in absolute terms—it's which platform delivers the best return for your specific needs, budget, and technical capability.

Over our 20 years building websites for small businesses, we've worked with every major platform. We've migrated dozens of sites from Wix to WordPress, from WordPress to Shopify, and occasionally back again. We've tracked the real costs—not the advertised prices, but the actual total expenditure including hidden fees, limitations, and workarounds. We've measured conversion rates, SEO performance, and long-term scalability across hundreds of sites.

This guide provides the honest comparison nobody else will give you. We'll show you the real costs, the genuine limitations, and exactly which businesses thrive on each platform. For context on how platform choice affects your overall website investment, see our comprehensive guide on The Real Cost of Running a WordPress Website.

Section 1: The Real Cost Breakdown by Platform

Marketing materials show one price. Your bank statement shows another. Here's what you actually pay.

WordPress (self-hosted via WordPress.org)

Year-one costs for a typical 8-page small business site:

Hosting: £180-600 (£15-50/month for managed WordPress hosting)
Domain: £10-15
Premium theme: £50-80 (one-time) or £200-250/year (theme builder subscription)
Essential plugins: £200-400 (SEO, forms, security, backups)
SSL certificate: £0 (included with most hosts)
Year-one total: £440-1,265

Ongoing annual costs:

Hosting: £180-600
Plugins: £200-400
Theme updates: £0-250 (if using theme builder)
Annual ongoing: £380-1,250

According to W3Techs' 2024 survey, WordPress powers 43.5% of all websites globally and 62% of sites using a content management system. This dominance creates a massive ecosystem—60,000+ free plugins, thousands of developers, and extensive documentation.

We built a Leicester accountancy site on WordPress in 2022: £240/year hosting (SiteGround), £59 Rank Math Pro, £79 WPForms, £99 Wordfence, £70 UpdraftPlus = £547 year one, £547 annually ongoing. Over 5 years: £2,735. The site generates 40-50 qualified leads annually. Cost per lead over 5 years: £1.37.

Wix

Year-one costs:

Business Basic plan: £204/year (£17/month)
Business Unlimited: £300/year (£25/month)
Business VIP: £420/year (£35/month)
Domain: Included first year, then £12/year
Apps/extensions: £0-300+ (many premium features cost extra)
Year-one total: £204-720

According to BuiltWith's 2024 data, Wix powers 3.8% of the top 1 million websites. The platform emphasises drag-and-drop simplicity and all-in-one convenience.

A Bournemouth cafe started on Wix Business Basic (£204/year). Within 6 months, they needed: online ordering (£180/year Wix Restaurants), booking system (£120/year), email marketing (£180/year), and upgraded to Business Unlimited for more storage (£300/year). Year-one actual cost: £984. Year two: £780. Over 5 years: £3,504.

The hidden cost: When they wanted advanced features Wix couldn't provide, they migrated to WordPress. Migration cost: £2,400. Total 2-year Wix investment lost: £1,764.

Squarespace

Year-one costs:

Business plan: £228/year (£19/month, billed annually)
Commerce Basic: £324/year (£27/month)
Commerce Advanced: £468/year (£39/month)
Domain: Included first year, then £15/year
Extensions: Limited marketplace, most features built-in
Year-one total: £228-468

BuiltWith reports Squarespace powers 2.1% of the top 1 million websites. The platform targets creative professionals and service businesses with design-focused templates.

A Cambridge photographer used Squarespace Commerce Basic (£324/year) for 4 years. Total cost: £1,356 (including domain after year one). The site looked beautiful but converted poorly—1.8% conversion rate vs. 4.2% industry average for photography sites. We rebuilt on WordPress with conversion optimisation: £3,800 build + £547/year ongoing. Year-one total: £4,347. But conversions jumped to 5.1%, generating 12 additional bookings annually at £800 average value. ROI: £9,600 additional revenue vs. £2,991 additional cost in year one.

Shopify

Year-one costs:

Basic plan: £228/year (£19/month, billed annually)
Shopify plan: £588/year (£49/month)
Advanced plan: £2,388/year (£199/month)
Domain: £12/year
Apps: £0-1,200+ (average store uses 6-8 paid apps)
Transaction fees: 2% (Basic), 1% (Shopify), 0.5% (Advanced) if not using Shopify Payments
Payment processing: 1.9% + 20p per transaction (Shopify Payments)
Year-one total: £240-3,600+ before transaction fees

According to Shopify's 2024 earnings report, the platform powers 4.4 million stores globally. It's the dominant e-commerce platform for small to mid-sized businesses.

A Bristol retailer sells £120,000 annually on Shopify. Costs: Basic plan (£228), 6 apps (£780/year average), payment processing at 1.9% + 20p (approximately £2,400 on £120,000 sales). Total annual cost: £3,408. That's 2.84% of revenue—acceptable for e-commerce.

But when they wanted to add a blog, membership area, and service bookings alongside products, Shopify's limitations became clear. Migrating to WooCommerce (WordPress): £6,800 build, £547/year ongoing, payment processing 1.4% + 20p (Stripe on WooCommerce, approximately £1,800 on £120,000). New annual cost: £2,347 after year one. Savings: £1,061 annually, plus gained flexibility for non-commerce features.

WordPress.com (hosted)

Year-one costs:

Personal plan: £48/year (£4/month)
Premium plan: £96/year (£8/month)
Business plan: £300/year (£25/month)
Commerce plan: £540/year (£45/month)
Year-one total: £48-540

WordPress.com is confusing—it's WordPress but hosted and limited by Automattic (WordPress's parent company). You can't install custom plugins on plans below Business, severely limiting functionality.

A Norwich consultant started on WordPress.com Business (£300/year). After 18 months (£450 spent), she realised she needed plugins the platform didn't allow. She migrated to self-hosted WordPress.org: £3,200 migration + £547/year ongoing. The £450 WordPress.com investment was lost entirely.

For a complete breakdown of WordPress costs and how they compare long-term, see our detailed guide: The Real Cost of Running a WordPress Website.

Section 2: Feature Limitations That Cost You Money

Advertised features look identical. Real-world usage reveals critical differences.

SEO capabilities

WordPress with proper SEO plugins (Rank Math Pro, Yoast SEO Premium) gives you complete control: custom schema markup, advanced meta settings, redirect management, XML sitemaps, breadcrumb control, and integration with every SEO tool available.

Wix has improved dramatically since 2019 but still has limitations. According to a 2023 Ahrefs study of 6.4 million domains, WordPress sites rank in the top 3 Google positions 46.1% more often than Wix sites with similar content and backlinks. The gap narrows for local searches but persists for competitive keywords.

We tested identical service pages (same content, similar design) on WordPress and Wix for a legal services keyword with 2,400 monthly UK searches. After 6 months with identical backlink profiles: WordPress site ranked position 7, Wix site ranked position 19. The WordPress site generated 47 organic leads, Wix generated 12. At £400 average client value, that's £14,000 additional revenue from better SEO.

Squarespace falls between Wix and WordPress—better than Wix, not as powerful as WordPress. Shopify's SEO is good for product pages but weak for content marketing and blogging.

Conversion optimization

WordPress with proper plugins (Thrive Optimize, Google Optimize integration, Convert) allows unlimited A/B testing, advanced heat mapping, session recording, and complete control over every conversion element.

Wix offers basic A/B testing on higher plans but limited to simple element tests. Squarespace has no native A/B testing—you need third-party tools that cost £50-200/month extra. Shopify has built-in A/B testing but only for product pages and checkout.

We optimised a WordPress e-commerce site through 12 months of systematic testing: CTA placement, button colours, product page layouts, checkout flow. Conversion rate improved from 2.1% to 4.8%—128% increase. On £180,000 annual traffic value, that's £86,400 additional revenue.

The same client's friend runs a similar business on Shopify. They can't run comparable tests without expensive apps (£200+/month) or technical workarounds. Their conversion rate has remained static at 2.3% for 2 years.

Custom functionality

WordPress: If you can imagine it, you can build it. Need a custom booking system with specific availability rules? Build it. Want integration with your proprietary CRM? Build it. Require a membership area with tiered access? Build it.

Wix, Squarespace, Shopify: You're limited to what the platform offers or what's available in their app marketplace. Need something custom? You're often out of luck or paying premium prices for limited solutions.

A Exeter training company needed: course bookings with prerequisites, certificate generation, progress tracking, and integration with their existing student management system. On WordPress: £8,400 custom development, exactly what they needed. On Wix or Squarespace: Impossible. On Shopify: Possible with apps costing £400+/month (£4,800/year) with limitations.

Performance and speed

According to HTTP Archive's 2024 Web Almanac, the median load time for WordPress sites is 2.5 seconds (with optimisation), Wix sites 3.8 seconds, Squarespace 3.2 seconds, and Shopify 2.1 seconds (product pages only).

Speed directly impacts conversions. Google's 2023 research shows each additional second of load time decreases mobile conversions by 7%. A 1.3-second difference between optimised WordPress (2.5s) and Wix (3.8s) represents approximately 9% fewer conversions.

We tested this with a Plymouth retailer: Their Wix site loaded in 4.1 seconds with 2.8% conversion rate. We rebuilt on WordPress, optimised to 1.8 seconds, and conversion rate jumped to 3.9%—39% increase. On 15,000 monthly visitors, that's 165 additional conversions monthly. At £85 average order value, that's £14,025 additional monthly revenue (£168,300 annually).

For more on how website speed affects your bottom line, see our guide on Website Speed Optimization for Conversions.

Section 3: Migration Costs and Platform Lock-In

Switching platforms isn't free. Understanding migration costs prevents expensive mistakes.

Migrating from Wix to WordPress

Wix doesn't provide a clean export. You can export blog posts (as XML) but not pages, designs, or custom functionality. Migration requires rebuilding the site from scratch.

Average migration cost we charge: £2,400-6,800 depending on complexity. A 12-page Wix site with blog, contact forms, and basic functionality: £2,800. A 40-page site with custom Wix apps and complex layouts: £6,200.

We've migrated 23 sites from Wix to WordPress since 2020. Average time on Wix before migration: 18 months. Average amount spent on Wix: £1,260. Total sunk cost (Wix fees + migration): £4,060-8,060. If they'd started on WordPress, total cost would have been: £3,294 (£547 × 1.5 years + £2,500 initial build).

Migrating from Squarespace to WordPress

Squarespace allows XML export of blog posts and basic page content, but designs don't transfer. Migration is cleaner than Wix but still requires rebuilding.

Average migration cost: £2,200-5,800. A Cambridge designer spent £1,296 over 4 years on Squarespace (£324/year), then paid us £3,400 to migrate to WordPress. Total invested: £4,696. If she'd started on WordPress: £3,688 (£547 × 4 years + £2,500 build). Lost to wrong initial platform choice: £1,008 plus 4 years of limited functionality.

Migrating from Shopify to WooCommerce

Shopify to WooCommerce migration is more complex—products, customers, orders, and integrations must transfer. But it's possible with minimal data loss.

Average migration cost: £4,200-9,800. A Manchester retailer spent £13,632 over 4 years on Shopify (£3,408/year including apps and processing). Migration to WooCommerce cost £6,800. New annual cost: £2,347. Break-even on migration: 6.4 months. Annual savings after that: £1,061.

Migrating from WordPress to other platforms

This is the easiest migration because WordPress gives you complete data ownership. Exporting content, images, and data is straightforward. But why would you migrate away from the most flexible platform?

We've done it twice in 20 years: A client needed Shopify's point-of-sale integration for retail stores (WordPress POS solutions weren't mature enough in 2019), and a client wanted Squarespace's ultra-simple editing after their in-house person left.

The platform lock-in calculation

Before choosing a platform, calculate the "switching cost"—what you'd pay to move if the platform doesn't work out.

Wix switching cost: £2,400-6,800 + sunk subscription fees
Squarespace switching cost: £2,200-5,800 + sunk subscription fees
Shopify switching cost: £4,200-9,800 + sunk subscription fees
WordPress switching cost: £0-2,400 (data export is free, redesign optional)

If you're 70% confident in your platform choice, multiply switching cost by 30% (your uncertainty) to get your "platform risk cost." Choosing Wix with £4,000 average switching cost and 30% uncertainty = £1,200 platform risk. That's a hidden cost nobody mentions.

Section 4: Which Platform for Which Business

Over 20 years and 500+ websites, we've identified clear patterns of platform success and failure.

Choose WordPress if you:

Need complete control and flexibility
Plan to scale significantly (50,000+ monthly visitors)
Require custom functionality
Want the best SEO performance
Have budget for proper development (£2,500-8,000 initial build)
Need advanced conversion optimisation
Want to own your platform completely
Plan to keep the site 5+ years

Success story: A Birmingham consulting firm invested £6,800 in WordPress in 2019. Over 5 years: £6,800 + (£547 × 5) = £9,535 total. The site generates 80-100 qualified leads annually at £8,400 average client value. They've closed 280 clients over 5 years (£2,352,000 revenue). Cost per client: £34.

Choose Wix if you:

Need a site live in under 2 weeks
Have under £500 budget
Will never need custom functionality
Are completely non-technical with no developer access
Run a simple business (5-10 pages, basic contact form)
Don't rely heavily on organic search traffic
Plan to redesign within 2-3 years anyway

Success story: A York hairdresser needed a simple site fast. Wix Business Basic (£204/year) with booking integration (£120/year). Total: £324/year. The site serves as a digital business card—clients find them on Google Maps, check the site for hours and prices, then book. SEO doesn't matter, functionality is simple, cost is minimal. Perfect fit.

Choose Squarespace if you:

Prioritise design aesthetics above all else
Run a creative business (photography, design, art)
Need a beautiful portfolio
Have simple functionality needs
Are willing to sacrifice flexibility for ease of use
Don't need advanced conversion optimisation

Success story: A Bristol interior designer uses Squarespace Commerce Basic (£324/year). Her portfolio is stunning, loads reasonably fast, and converts at 3.2% (acceptable for her industry). She updates it herself easily. The limitation—can't A/B test or implement advanced conversion tactics—doesn't matter because her business runs on referrals and her portfolio's visual impact.

Choose Shopify if you:

Sell primarily physical products
Need point-of-sale integration for retail locations
Want the easiest e-commerce setup
Don't need extensive content marketing
Are willing to pay percentage-of-sales fees
Need multi-channel selling (Amazon, eBay, social media)

Success story: A Cardiff gift shop sells £240,000 annually. Shopify plan (£588) + apps (£960) + payment processing 1.9% (£4,560) = £6,108 annually (2.5% of revenue). They use Shopify POS in their physical shop, sell on their website, Amazon, and Instagram Shopping—all managed from one dashboard. The integration is worth the cost.

Choose WordPress.com if you:

Honestly, we can't think of a scenario where WordPress.com makes sense. If you need simplicity, Wix or Squarespace are simpler. If you need power, WordPress.org (self-hosted) is more powerful. WordPress.com is the worst of both worlds—WordPress complexity with platform limitations.

For understanding how platform choice affects your overall website investment and conversion performance, see our guides on The Real Cost of Running a WordPress Website and Website Conversion Optimization for Small Businesses: Turn Visitors into Customers.

Section 5: The Long-Term Cost Reality

Marketing focuses on monthly fees. Smart businesses calculate 5-year total cost of ownership.

5-year cost comparison: Service business (10-page site)

WordPress:

Initial build: £3,500
Year 1-5 ongoing: £547 × 5 = £2,735
Total: £6,235

Wix Business Unlimited:

Year 1-5: £300 × 5 = £1,500
Apps/extensions average: £240 × 5 = £1,200
Total: £2,700

Wix appears £3,535 cheaper over 5 years. But factor in:

WordPress site ranks higher (47% better according to Ahrefs), generating more organic leads
WordPress converts better (average 4.2% vs. Wix 3.1% in our testing)
WordPress allows unlimited optimisation and testing

If the WordPress site generates just 15 additional leads over 5 years at £800 average value, that's £12,000 additional revenue—£5,765 net profit after the £6,235 investment vs. £2,700 Wix investment. The "more expensive" platform delivered £5,765 more profit.

5-year cost comparison: E-commerce (£150,000 annual sales)

WooCommerce (WordPress):

Initial build: £6,800
Year 1-5 ongoing: £1,200 × 5 = £6,000 (hosting + plugins + extensions)
Payment processing (Stripe 1.4% + 20p): £2,250/year × 5 = £11,250
Total: £24,050

Shopify:

Year 1-5: £588 × 5 = £2,940 (Shopify plan)
Apps: £960 × 5 = £4,800
Payment processing (1.9% + 20p): £3,000/year × 5 = £15,000
Total: £22,740

Shopify appears £1,310 cheaper. But:

WooCommerce allows unlimited products, variants, and customisation (Shopify charges for advanced features)
WooCommerce integrates with any payment processor (Shopify charges 2% extra if you don't use Shopify Payments)
WooCommerce allows complete control over checkout optimisation

If WooCommerce's superior checkout optimisation improves conversion by just 0.5% (conservative based on our testing), that's £7,500 additional revenue over 5 years—£6,190 net profit after the £1,310 additional cost.

The scalability factor

Platforms have traffic limits. Exceed them, and costs skyrocket.

Wix Business VIP (£420/year) supports "unlimited" bandwidth, but their fair use policy throttles sites exceeding 100GB/month. A busy site with video content hits that easily. Next step: Wix Enterprise (custom pricing, typically £3,000-10,000/year).

WordPress hosting scales predictably. Outgrow your £25/month plan? Upgrade to £50/month. Need more? Move to £100/month VPS. Same platform, same site, just more resources.

A Coventry training company grew from 5,000 to 80,000 monthly visitors over 3 years. On WordPress: hosting increased from £25/month to £65/month (£480/year increase). On Wix: they'd have needed Enterprise pricing (£5,000+/year increase) or migrated (£4,000 one-time cost).

Conclusion

The Betamax vs VHS format war taught us that technical superiority doesn't always win—practical advantages and long-term value matter more. WordPress is technically superior, but that doesn't make it the right choice for every business.

For UK small businesses with growth ambitions, technical capability (or budget for developers), and a 5+ year horizon, WordPress delivers the best long-term value. The higher initial investment (£2,500-8,000) is recovered through better SEO performance, superior conversion rates, and lower long-term costs.

For businesses needing something simple immediately, with minimal budget and no growth plans, Wix or Squarespace provide adequate solutions at lower entry costs. Just understand the limitations and calculate the switching cost if you outgrow the platform.

For e-commerce-focused businesses, Shopify offers unmatched ease of use and integration. But if you need content marketing alongside products or want to minimise transaction fees, WooCommerce on WordPress delivers better long-term economics.

The worst choice is WordPress.com—you get WordPress complexity without WordPress power. And the second-worst choice is choosing based on monthly fees alone without calculating 5-year total cost of ownership, migration risk, and revenue impact.

Start by honestly assessing: What's your budget? What's your technical capability? What's your growth trajectory? How important is SEO? Do you need custom functionality? Answer those questions, then match platform to needs—not marketing to hype.

For the complete picture of WordPress costs and how platform choice affects your overall website investment, see our pillar guide: The Real Cost of Running a WordPress Website. And for understanding how platform capabilities impact your ability to convert visitors into customers, see Website Conversion Optimization for Small Businesses: Turn Visitors into Customers.

Next steps:

Calculate your 5-year total cost of ownership for your top 2-3 platform choices
Factor in migration costs (multiply by your uncertainty percentage)
Assess your technical capability honestly
Schedule a free platform consultation with our team to discuss your specific situation

Frequently Asked Questions

Is WordPress cheaper than Wix or Squarespace?

WordPress has higher upfront costs (£2,500-8,000 for professional development) but lower long-term costs. Over 5 years, a WordPress site costs approximately £6,235 (£3,500 build + £547/year × 5) while Wix costs £2,700 (£300/year × 5 plus £240/year average for apps). However, WordPress typically generates more leads through better SEO (46% better rankings according to Ahrefs) and higher conversion rates (4.2% vs. 3.1% in our testing across 50+ sites).

If your WordPress site generates just 15 additional leads over 5 years at £800 average value (conservative for most service businesses), that's £12,000 additional revenue—making the "more expensive" platform £5,765 more profitable. The calculation changes if you're a simple local business where SEO doesn't matter and you need minimal functionality—then Wix's lower cost makes sense. Calculate based on lead value and volume, not just platform fees.

Can I migrate from Wix or Squarespace to WordPress later?

Yes, but migration isn't free or simple. Wix doesn't provide clean exports—you can export blog posts but not pages, designs, or custom functionality. Migration requires rebuilding the site from scratch, costing £2,400-6,800 depending on complexity. Squarespace allows better data export but designs don't transfer, costing £2,200-5,800 to migrate.

We've migrated 23 sites from Wix to WordPress since 2020. Average client spent £1,260 on Wix over 18 months before migrating, then paid £2,800 average for migration—total £4,060. If they'd started on WordPress, total cost would have been £3,294. The wrong initial platform choice cost them £766 plus 18 months of limitations. Before choosing Wix or Squarespace, calculate your "platform risk cost"—if there's 30% chance you'll outgrow it, multiply migration cost by 30% and add that to your decision.

Which platform is best for SEO?

WordPress with proper SEO plugins (Rank Math Pro, Yoast SEO Premium) delivers the best SEO performance. According to a 2023 Ahrefs study of 6.4 million domains, WordPress sites rank in Google's top 3 positions 46.1% more often than Wix sites with similar content and backlinks. Squarespace falls between Wix and WordPress. Shopify's SEO is good for product pages but weak for content marketing.

We tested this directly: identical service pages (same content, similar design) on WordPress and Wix for a legal keyword with 2,400 monthly UK searches. After 6 months with identical backlink profiles, WordPress ranked position 7 (47 organic leads), Wix ranked position 19 (12 leads). At £400 average client value, that's £14,000 additional revenue from better SEO. If organic search is important to your business, WordPress's SEO advantage pays for itself quickly. If you rely on referrals, paid ads, or location-based discovery, the SEO difference matters less.

Is Shopify or WooCommerce better for e-commerce?

Shopify is easier to set up and manage (average setup time: 2-4 weeks) while WooCommerce is more flexible and cheaper long-term. For a business doing £150,000 annual sales: Shopify costs £22,740 over 5 years (£588/year platform + £960/year apps + £3,000/year payment processing at 1.9%). WooCommerce costs £24,050 (£6,800 build + £1,200/year ongoing + £2,250/year payment processing at 1.4%).

Shopify appears £1,310 cheaper but WooCommerce allows unlimited products, complete checkout control, and integration with any payment processor. If WooCommerce's superior checkout optimisation improves conversion by just 0.5%, that's £7,500 additional revenue over 5 years. Choose Shopify if you need point-of-sale integration for physical retail, want the easiest setup, and don't need extensive content marketing. Choose WooCommerce if you want complete control, plan to do content marketing alongside products, or want to minimise transaction fees.

What happens to my website if Wix or Squarespace shuts down?

If Wix or Squarespace shuts down (unlikely but possible), you'd lose your website unless you export your content beforehand. You don't own the platform or code—you're renting access. Both platforms allow content export (blog posts, basic page content) but not designs or functionality. You'd need to rebuild elsewhere from scratch.

With WordPress, you own everything—code, design, content, database. If your hosting company shuts down, you simply move your files to another host (takes 1-2 hours). We've moved WordPress sites between hosts 100+ times over 20 years—it's straightforward. This ownership matters for businesses planning to sell, franchise, or maintain long-term digital assets. A Southampton franchise system chose WordPress specifically because they needed to own and replicate their site across 12 locations—impossible on Wix or Squarespace.

Can I build a WordPress site myself or do I need a developer?

You can build a basic WordPress site yourself using page builders (Elementor, Beaver Builder, Divi), but professional development delivers better results for business-critical sites. DIY WordPress sites typically take 40-80 hours to build if you're learning as you go, and often have performance, security, or conversion issues that hurt business results.

A DIY WordPress site might cost £547/year (hosting + plugins) but take 60 hours of your time. If your time is worth £30/hour, that's £1,800 opportunity cost—total £2,347 in year one. Professional development costs £2,500-8,000 but delivers faster, better results. We recommend DIY for hobby sites or if you enjoy learning web development. For business sites where conversions matter, professional development pays for itself through better performance. A middle ground: hire a developer for initial setup (£1,500-3,000) and handle content updates yourself.

How much does it really cost to run a WordPress website vs Wix?

WordPress costs £440-1,265 in year one (hosting £180-600, plugins £200-400, theme £50-250) and £380-1,250 annually ongoing, plus initial development £2,500-8,000. Total 5-year cost: £6,235-14,250. Wix costs £204-720/year depending on plan, plus £0-300/year for apps. Total 5-year cost: £1,020-5,100. Wix appears significantly cheaper.

However, factor in business impact: WordPress sites in our portfolio generate 47% more organic traffic (better SEO), convert 35% better (more optimisation control), and scale without platform switching costs. A service business generating £120,000 annual revenue saw these improvements worth £18,000 additional revenue in year one on WordPress vs. Wix. The "more expensive" platform delivered £3,750 more profit after accounting for higher costs. Calculate based on your business metrics, not just platform fees. If you're a simple local business where these factors don't matter, Wix's lower cost makes sense.

Should I start with Wix and migrate to WordPress later?

No, unless you absolutely cannot afford WordPress initially and need something live immediately. Starting on Wix then migrating costs more than starting on WordPress. Example: 18 months on Wix (£450-900 depending on plan) + migration to WordPress (£2,400-6,800) + WordPress setup (£547/year) = £3,397-8,247 total. Starting on WordPress: £2,500-8,000 build + £547/year = £3,047-8,547 in 18 months.

The costs are similar, but starting on WordPress gives you 18 months of better SEO performance, better conversion rates, and no migration disruption. The only scenario where Wix-first makes sense: you need a site live in under 2 weeks, have under £500 budget, and are 80%+ confident you'll never need WordPress capabilities. Otherwise, save longer and start with WordPress, or use a WordPress subscription service (£150-250/month with no upfront cost) to get WordPress benefits with Wix-like payment structure.

A subsidiary of NerveCentral